2. Buccaneer

There are way too many good seafood restaurants in Aruba to waste a night on the Buccaneer. This restaurant was recommended to us, but we were highly disappointed. While the staff was fun and friendly, the food was just so-so. Everything is drenched in rich sauces, which makes you wonder how fresh it really is. The prices are somewhat lower than other seafood places in Aruba and the fish tanks at every table may make this child-friendly but we'll definitely be skipping this one next time!