Featuring: 10Best, Southern Living, Sunset, Coastal Living, Cottage Living, Southern Accents and Cooking Light

 

Erie
  Best Restaurants

Print this Page  Email this Page

More in Erie Restaurants:

User Suggested
Discounted Gift Certificates
Advanced Search
 
Keyword: (4 or more characters)
Cuisine
Features
Type
Neighborhood
Price
[view all]

Your Favorite Erie Business not listed?
Click here to share it »

Arnone's

607 W 18th St, Erie, PA 16502 · 814-459-9333

User Rating:  Rating: 1 / 5   (Rate It)

My Suitcase:   (Add to My Suitcase)

Dress: BCBC: Business Casual
Outdoor Dining: None

ERIE. Well known for being one of the best among a number of topnotch Erie Italian eateries, Arnone's grew from humble beginnings. Once a small deli and bakery, this area favorite has now added a charming restaurant just across the street from the original location. Menu selections include starters like calamari and steamed mussels, and main dish items center around pizzas with made-from-scratch dough and pastas adorned with savory, handcrafted sauces. Desserts are found in the form of tempting tiramisu and cannoli. Plus, homemade breads come warm from the bakery and compliment most meals.

Celebrities Restaurant

4940 Peach St, Erie, PA 16509 · 814-864-2022

User Rating:   (Rate It!)

My Suitcase:   (Add to My Suitcase)

Reservations: Recommended
Dress: BCBC: Business Casual
Outdoor Dining: None

ERIE. Part of Erie's Station Dinner Theatre complex, this stylish theater-themed restaurant features costumed waitstaff who deliver show-stopping dishes with panache. Goodies like Garbo's Grilled Chicken Salad and Rooney's Open Faced Prime Rib bring the chef standing ovations from satisfied diners. In addition to the marquee-styled entrance and Hollywood decor, the interior also includes a refurbished 1922 Pullman railroad car that exudes romantic ambiance. Reservations accepted.

George's Restaurant

2614 Glenwood Park Ave, Erie, PA 16508 · 814-455-0860

User Rating:   (Rate It!)

My Suitcase:   (Add to My Suitcase)

Avg. Entrée: $$1 - $15
Dress: CC: Casual
Outdoor Dining: None

ERIE. A 75 year-old Erie tradition, George's has been serving three squares a day to Erieites of multiple generations. From omelets and oatmeal with blueberries in the morning to the Eriesistable Chopped Sirloin and George's famous "smashed potatoes" for dinner, the menu offers hearty and satisfying meals. Also know for its generosity, this restaurant offers freebies on different weeknights – Mondays find kids eating free with paying adults and Thursdays showcase free pie with the purchase of a main course.

Joe Roots Grill

2826 w 8th St,, Erie, PA 16505 · 814-836-7668

User Rating:   (Rate It!)

My Suitcase:   (Add to My Suitcase)

Avg. Entrée: $$1 - $15
Dress: CC: Casual
Outdoor Dining: None

ERIE. Named for a native who lived on Presque Isle from 1860 to 1910, this grill boasts an outstanding location on Peninsula Drive, the gateway to Erie's most notable natural attraction – Presque Isle State Park. Homemade main dishes, crisp salads and fresh seafood line the menu, and the sizzling steaks and hearty burgers are perpetual favorites. Try the shrimp salad, the snow crab legs or the St. Louis ribs. The atmosphere is laid-back and convivial – perfect for an eatery that's a stop along the way to Erie's sun and sand.

Matthew's Trattoria

153 E 13th St, Erie, PA 16503 · 814-459-6458

User Rating:  Rating: 5 / 5   (Rate It)

My Suitcase:   (Add to My Suitcase)

Reservations: Recommended
Dress: BCBC: Business Casual
Outdoor Dining:

ERIE. Matthews seamlessly blends live jazz music with authentic Italian cuisine in an environment that's upscale yet friendly. Start with the tasty brushcetta trattoria or the spicy stuffed banana peppers, and then select from main courses like chicken Romano and pasta primavera. A martini lounge, stocked with signature drinks like the Blue Sapphire and the Raspberry Cosmopolitan, adds to the draw of this trendy spot. Beer, wine by the bottle or glass and specialty coffees are also available. Outdoor patio dining makes for the perfect dinner setting during warm weather.

Pufferbelly on French Street

414 French St, Erie, PA 16507 · 814-454-1557

User Rating:  Rating: 4 / 5   (Rate It)

My Suitcase:   (Add to My Suitcase)

Avg. Entrée: $$$16 - $30
Reservations: Recommended
Dress: BCBC: Business Casual
Outdoor Dining:

ERIE. Set in a turn of the century firehouse, the Pufferbelly prides itself on its original, eclectic menu. Baked brie with almonds, vegetable lasagna rollups and firehouse chili doused with a generous helping of cheese get diners headed in the right direction while they peruse the list of tasty main dishes – an assortment that includes quesadillas, steaks and seafood. The interior space is casual and charming with a brass firepole and an authentic "Pufferbelly" (an old-timey horse-drawn fire wagon) while the outside features streetside dining.

Serafini's

2642 W 12th St, Erie, PA 16505 · 814-838-8111

User Rating:  Rating: 2 / 5   (Rate It)

My Suitcase:   (Add to My Suitcase)

Avg. Entrée: $$1 - $15
Reservations: Recommended
Dress: CC: Casual
Outdoor Dining: None

ERIE. Upon entering the threshold of Serafini's, your mouth begins to water at the tantalizing smells of home-cooked food in the form of wedding soup, chicken cacciatore, veal parmesan, lasagna and other beloved Italian classics. The kitchen claims, and most diners agree, that the success is in the sauce. It's made fresh daily and has been rewarding diners since 1938. As an added bonus, savory steaks and prime rib can also be found on the menu. Takeout provides for lunch and dinner on the go.

Smuggler's Wharf

3 State St, Erie, PA 16507 · 814-459-4273

User Rating:  Rating: 1 / 5   (Rate It)

My Suitcase:   (Add to My Suitcase)

Avg. Entrée: $$1 - $15
Dress: CC: Casual
Outdoor Dining:

ERIE. Enjoy the charm of Erie's lakefront by dining at this seafood eatery that's perched right on Dobbins Landing. Their outdoor deck dining provides views of both the bay and the city skyline. A nautical feel pervades the restaurant's interior, and the menu serves up goodies like langostino-crab cakes, coconut shrimp, crab encrusted chicken breast and yellowtail snapper. Smuggler's also serves Sunday Brunch, where buffet tables are laden with all sorts of treats from land and sea.

Stonehouse Inn

4753 West Lake Rd, Erie, PA 16505 · 814-838-9296

User Rating:  Rating: 1 / 5   (Rate It)

My Suitcase:   (Add to My Suitcase)

Reservations: Required
Dress: BCBC: Business Casual
Outdoor Dining: None

ERIE. Housed in a charming stone cottage, this restaurant seems to have been plucked from the English countryside and transported to the shores of Lake Erie. Sophistication and class define this restaurant at every turn, from the cosmopolitan cuisine to the expert wait staff and the talented chef. Both outdoors and in, the ambiance is one of gentility and romance – swans, a waterfall and a pond outside, antiques and a warm, glowing fireplace within. Chicken and shallot fricassee, black angus prime rib and lobster-stuffed filet mignon are just a sampling of the culinary delights that await. Reservations are an absolute must.

Restaurants

Your favorite business not listed?
Click here to recommend it!

Looking for a restaurant? We've explored the options, checked with critics, and pounded the pavement to offer only the best. Recommendations come complete with contact information and a brief description highlighting the important features of the restaurant. Fit our choices to your mood, or let us guide your tastes. You'll likely find a few places that not even locals know about.

 

Discounted Gift Certificates

10Best Lists

Find everything you need to know about Erie.