2. Michael Anthony's

WOW!
I was about to give up on restaurants on Hilton Head Island... Thank God I decided to go to Michael Anthony's! We had a wonderful server and an outstanding meal. The scallop app was perfect. My wife had the gnocchi, which was the best I've ever tasted (& a perfect sauce). I had the Alaskan Halibut special and it was beyond words. We finished the meal with a pair of deserts that were great. In short, I will go back every time I return to HHI. It is a perfect place to have a romantic meal with your spouse that is worth the money and the calories!