Indianapolis Guide  » Indianapolis Restaurants  » Indianapolis Best Restaurants

7. Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant

1031 E 54th St, Indianapolis, IN 46220  (Map)
317-259-9412

Rate/Review this Business (6)
Write a Review

User Reviews for Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant

Breakdown
5 star:
 (5)
4 star:
 (0)
3 star:
 (0)
2 star:
 (0)
1 star:
 (1)
"Gourmand2"
more than a month ago

This restaurant typically gets excellent reviews, but my wife and I are living proof that not every dining experience in popular restaurants is good. They don't take reservations, so we dutifully waited at the bar for our table, having drinks and appetizers. We noticed that people who arrived after us were being seated before us, so we settled the bar bill and questioned the "hostess", who became remarkably belligerent, and kept us standing whil she seated others who had again arrived after us. She eventually seated us with ill-humor, and the waitress (apparently briefed on our appalling behavior) was pompous and unhelpful. We have been tempted to go back in order to see what is so great about this place, but the experience was so awful that we cannot bring ourselves to do it. In short, I would say go here at your own risk. Chances are it will be great, but when it's bad it is REALLY bad.

Was this review Helpful?

+9
-1
"Indianapolisjustin"
more than a month ago

The restaurant is one of the most attractive in the city and the patio is wonderful. We live in the neighborhood and we walk there all the time. The food is great and you can't beat the price

Was this review Helpful?

+7
-3

Write a Review

Recent User Activity in Indianapolis

"10Best Guest"

The Vogue

Review Posted

"10Best Guest"

Landsharks

Review Posted

"10Best Guest"

The Rathskeller

Review Posted

Similar Businesses

10Best Restaurants similar to:
Mama Carolla's Old Italian Restaurant