Long Island Guide  » Long Island Restaurants  » Long Island Brunch

6. Cooperage Inn

2218 Sound Ave, Baiting Hollow, NY 11933  (Map)
631-727-8994

Rate/Review this Business (5)
Write a Review

User Reviews for Cooperage Inn

Breakdown
5 star:
 (1)
4 star:
 (2)
3 star:
 (0)
2 star:
 (1)
1 star:
 (1)
"alrbo"
more than a month ago

THE BEST!
The lady who was outside they probably meant you can wait or sit outside the fall festival which is different thing entirely, its like a gourmet small band fest. best pot pie in my life by the way inside and fall festival is two different things/menus they should have informed you of that better. But anyway their food is amazing the atmosphere is country but modern and kind io ritzy looking as well. weekends at cooperidge in fall there is nothing like it. the pumpkin spiced ale has brown sugar/pumpkin spice rimmed on the glass. its a classy festival! pumpkin bread roasted corn...ribs pot pies that are the best. they do have portapotties yes for the festival but they have elmo, a pony and a hay cove for the kids. its like the place you go when your financially good with the kids when your the hip party parent but your just not trashy. The inside is just as classy but more on the scene to a sophisticated dinner the food is really good too. i feel sorry for someone who listens to the liar up there and the old woman who was confused to that she was partaking in the fall festival and not the serious dinner inside. go here!

Was this review Helpful?

+0
-1
"Port JeffAzure"
more than a month ago

Food was overpriced and horrible. Would not go back. Not to mention tiny portion size coupled with automatic 20% gratuity on a small party. Disappointed.

Was this review Helpful?

+2
-1
"Veronica85819"
more than a month ago

Having eaten at the Cooperate Inn before, I decided to bring my house guest to the restaurant for dinner on Sunday 10/03/04. It was crowded and the women taking names said we could eat outside because it was the same menu and we would not have to wait. Some of my guest were elderly women who had to use the bathroom. We were told if we were not eating inside, we had to use the outhouses provided outside. I could not believe such treatment. The outhouses were disgustingly dirty having been used all day, the water to wash your hands was no longer working and overall they were in terrible condition. When we told the tall blonde woman inside the restaurant who was taking name, she got extremely rude told us she was not allowing pumpkin pickers to keep coming in and using the bathrooms and refused to allow a 75 year old women use the bathroom. Now if we were just off the street, I can well agree with her but since we wanted to eat inside and we were told there would be a 45 minute wait and that the service outside was quicker, I cannot imagine not allowing guest to use the bathroom since we were eating at the restaurant but only outside. I was totally humiliated for my guest, and I have to say, I will never set foot in your restaurant again. How can you expect people to use an outhouse and then eat dinner. It’s absolutely disgusting. You could not even wash your hands. Also, the menu was not the same it was basically more of a picnic type of menu geared towards parents with young children. We then went to The Lobster Roll down the street, we have a wonderful dinner spent well over $300.00 and were treated with respect. If I owned The Cooperage Inn I would definitely give that woman at the door a lesson on how to treat people especially elderly women. There is no excuse for rudeness. Also I might add, that my guest were registered nurses as well as one physician and she said that the outhouses were absolutely a Board of Health issue that definitely needs to be reported.

Was this review Helpful?

+8
-2

Write a Review

Recent User Activity in Long Island

"10Best Guest"

Da Ugo

Review Posted

"10Best Guest"

Cooperage Inn

Review Posted

"10Best Guest"

Jones Beach State Park

Review Posted

Similar Businesses

10Best Restaurants similar to:
Cooperage Inn