New York Guide  » New York Restaurants  » New York Deli

7. Sarge's Deli

548 3rd Ave, between 36th and 37th St, New York, NY 10016  (Map)
212-679-0442 · 877-727-4371 · FAX: 212-545-1540

Rate/Review this Business (13)
Write a Review

User Reviews for Sarge's Deli

Breakdown
5 star:
 (6)
4 star:
 (1)
3 star:
 (3)
2 star:
 (1)
1 star:
 (2)
"neni"
Nov 10, 2009

Stale, dried out bacon smelling like fish, cold waffle served with frozen butter, cold coffee, Sunday 3:00am

Was this review Helpful?

+0
-0
"10Best Guest"
more than a month ago

Had Mold on my burger bread
Dirty ,Dirty ,Dirty place.

Was this review Helpful?

+3
-1
"10Best Guest"
more than a month ago

pastrami guy
I've been to all the Delis in the city and they are for the most part very good but hands down Sarge's has the best pastrami and corned beef I have ever tried. I don't know how they do it but they are just melt in your mouth delicious.

Was this review Helpful?

+0
-3
"10Best Guest"
more than a month ago

Best Brisket in the world. Melts in your mouth!

Was this review Helpful?

+0
-4
"Robert57301"
more than a month ago

When I come into New York from Pittsburgh, I make sure to stay in Murray Hill. First thing after checking into a hotel is to head straight to Sarge's Deli for the best center-cut tongue in the city. Definitely the best deli in New York.

Was this review Helpful?

+0
-3
"Robert33036"
more than a month ago

It's no coincedence I've been going for breakfast and lunch almost every Sunday. They're wonderful people and the pastrami, matzoh ball soup and eggs with hash have never failed. There is always a consistency of excellence.

Was this review Helpful?

+0
-3
"Marie & Mike C"
more than a month ago

Have been eating there for more than 36 years. Briskets, burgers, soups, salads, breakfast foods - ALL GREAT. Their brown gravy is GREAT!

Was this review Helpful?

+0
-5

Write a Review

Recent User Activity in New York

"10Best Guest"

Katz's Deli

Review Posted

"RCG"

Garden Cafe

Review Posted

"10Best Guest"

Carnegie Deli

Review Posted