Best Restaurants in the Old Town District of Key West
Restaurants in Old Town, Key West aren't known for being cheap, but there are several that are well worth a splurge and others that offer a great value for your dollar. Fresh seafood is on just about every menu, and but there is a wide variety of international cuisines to choose from as well. As the name states, Colombian Grace serves homemade family recipes from Colombia, while El Siboney offers authentic Cuban dishes.
For a romantic Italian establishment, La Trattoria offers a fine-dining atmosphere and excellent pasta dishes while newcomer Duetto's Pizza and Gelato offers take out and delivery. Michael's is a long-time... Read more »
Yes, it will be packed with tourists but Blue Heaven lives up to the hype.
Local Expert Tip: "Ask for extra lobster meat. It's $3 extra but you get a pile."
For classic fine dining and Italian cuisine, you can't go wrong with La Trattoria.
Local Expert Tip: "On Mondays, the martinis are just $5. "
Duetto's serves real Italian pizza and gelato in Old Town that will have you returning the next day!
Local Expert Tip: "Ask them to mix a flavor or two for you!"
Michael's is a long-time favorite that is ideal for date night, reunions, or just a great meal out on the town.
Local Expert Tip: "Michael's now offers a light-side menu Sunday through Thursday until 7:30 pm."
- Cuisine: Colombian
Home style Colombian cuisine and a casual environment is the recipe to success at this hidden jewel.
Local Expert Tip: "Be aware that breakfast is only available on Saturday and Sunday from 9 a.m. until 1 p.m."
No matter what time of day, AZUR has a solid selection of delicious menu items and impeccable service.
Local Expert Tip: "Don't forget the mimosas!"
This funky gastropub has a fun atmosphere and an eclectic, modern menu.
Local Expert Tip: "Who says you can't pair wine with bacon?"
This no-frills place serves Cuban food that's as close as you can get to being in Cuba - literally.
Local Expert Tip: "Watch the daily specials for some real treats like the white bean soup on Mondays and Oxtail on Saturdays."
Santiago's has great specials at happy hour and mouthwatering tapas in the evenings.
Local Expert Tip: "Make reservations online using Open Table."
- Neighborhood: Old Town
With so many restaurants focused on the appetizers and mains, a venue entirely dedicated to desserts is a welcome treat!
Local Expert Tip: "It's so scandalous that reservations are advised."
From Our Partners
Ready for Your Dream Vacation?