As featured in 10Best's "Pizza" list!

Totonno Pizzeria Napolitano Photo courtesy of 1ieve
  • 1524 Neptune Ave

    between 15th and 16th Sts

    Brooklyn, NY 11224

  • Phone: 718-372-8606

Edit Edit Business Info

Write a Review

New Feature!



This homey, coal fired pizza spot may seem remote, way out in Coney Island, but pie-master Anthony "Totonno" Pero had a plan when he opened in 1924. The train lines were just being built, providing a kind of access and mobility not previously enjoyed by New Yorkers. Before the trains, he honed his trade at famed pizzeria Lombardi's and sold his string-tied pizzas out of a truck, a perfect resume for the creator of one of the city's best pizza joints. The Neptune Avenue eatery is bright and casual, featuring checked tile floors and framed accolaides lining the walls. TRAIN: N, B, D, F to Coney Island-Stillwell Ave





Insider Tips

Julia Smith

Ten Best Logo 03 Local Expert Says:

"If you make the trek, get there early. The dough is made fresh each day, so when they run out, it's over."