As featured in 10Best's "Deli" list!

Eisenberg Sandwich Shop
  • 174 5th Ave

    between 22nd & 23rd St

    New York, NY 10010

  • Phone: 212-675-5096

Edit Edit Business Info
  • Hours:

    Mon-Fri 6:30am-8pm

    Sat 8am-6pm

    Sun 8am-4pm

  • Cuisines:
    American, Deli
  • Pricing:
    Average Main Course Price is $6

Write a Review

New Feature!



They don't make 'em like this anymore. A narrow, no-frills counter joint, Eisenberg's sits in the shadow of the Instagram-worthy Flatiron Building, on a stretch of Fifth Avenue that also includes an Armani Exchange boutique and barn-sized Club Monaco. The sandwiches here are not of the gargantuan, Katz's variety, but what they lack in size they make up for in authenticity. Try the justly famous tuna salad, a revelation served with an ice cream scoop, or a hearty beef brisket sandwich with a side of crisp, straight-from-the-fryer onion rings. And don't skimp on the slaw. New York deli-style coleslaw is different from other region's -- less vinegar, more mayo -- and Eisenberg's version is does good by the house motto: "Raising New York's cholesteral since 1929."





Insider Tips

Emily Saladino

Ten Best Logo 03 Local Expert Says:

"Couple your meal with a lime rickey or egg cream, two New York City counter classics."

Best for Deli Because: Eisenberg's is a taste of the past, served between two soft, perfectly grainy slices of marbled rye.