search

Go to 10 West for Indiana's best chicken and noodles

Advertisement

This winning iconic state dish is made from scratch

Indiana’s beloved chicken and noodles (sometimes called Amish noodles) is a comfort food favorite made with just three main ingredients: chicken, egg noodles (often made from scratch) and mashed potatoes. It’s carb-heavy, hearty and nostalgic.

  • 10 West
    Cicero

    On the Hearty Bowls menu at 10 West in Cicero, hungry diners will find a traditional chicken and noodles, made from scratch and served over mashed potatoes – “A tribute to Mom.”
    Photo courtesy of 10 West

  • Covered Bridge Restaurant
    Cayuga

    Chicken and noodles are only available at Covered Bridge Restaurant on weekends, but it’s worth the wait. They’re made in house with white chicken breast, and they come with a choice of two sides (there are around 20 to choose from).
    Photo courtesy of Covered Bridge Restaurant

  • The Country Post
    Huntington

    The Country Post is a family style, comfort food restaurant in the town of Huntington. Homemade chicken and Amish noodles come ladled over a generous heap of mashed potatoes.
    Photo courtesy of The Country Post

  • Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery
    Shipshewana

    The Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery in Shipshewana specializes in homestyle cooking. Their chicken and noodles are made fresh with chunks of chicken and homemade noodles ladled over real, creamy mashed potatoes.
    Photo courtesy of Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery

  • Under the Arch Restaurant
    Marshall

    Fans of Indiana chicken and noodles should make their way to Under the Arch Restaurant in Marshall on Sundays, when the lunch buffet features a homemade version, along with several meats, corn pudding, vegetables, cobblers and cakes.
    Photo courtesy of Under the Arch Restaurant

  • Gray Brothers Cafeteria
    Mooresville

    Gray Brothers has been serving homestyle means since 1944. While the menu offerings change day to day, homemade chicken noodles and mashed potatoes are always available.
    Photo courtesy of iStock / DarrenFisher

  • Das Dutchman Essenhaus
    Middlebury

    Das Dutchman Essenhaus calls itself an “Amish Country Kitchen” where guests are invited to sit down and share a meal. The popular chicken and noodles comes with a heaping portion of egg noodles made in house served over mashed potatoes.
    Photo courtesy of Das Dutchman Essenhaus

  • Shipshewana Trading Place Auction Restaurant
    Shipshewana

    At the Shipshewana Trading Place Auction Restaurant, chicken and noodles are a house specialty. Noodles are made in house and served with hand-picked chicken, mashed potatoes and coleslaw.
    Photo courtesy of Shipshewana Trading Place Auction & Flea Market

  • Courtney's Kitchen
    Noblesville

    The Courtney's Kitchen take on chicken and noodles features a thick chicken broth, white breast chicken meat and rolled out noodles (dumplings) served alongside homemade mashed potatoes and vegetables.
    Photo courtesy of Courtney's Kitchen

  • Kopper Kettle Inn Restaurant
    Morristown

    The Kopper Kettle Inn Restaurant in Morristown has been serving Indiana classics from more than 91 years. To try their chicken and noodles, you’ll have to visit on a Thursday when they’re on special.
    Photo courtesy of iStock / DarrenFisher

The top 10 winners in the category Best Chicken & Noodles in Indiana are as follows:

  1. 10 West - Cicero
  2. Covered Bridge Restaurant - Cayuga
  3. The Country Post - Huntington
  4. Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery - Shipshewana
  5. Under the Arch Restaurant - Marshall
  6. Gray Brothers Cafeteria - Mooresville
  7. Das Dutchman Essenhaus - Middlebury
  8. Shipshewana Trading Place Auction Restaurant - Shipshewana
  9. Courtney's Kitchen - Noblesville
  10. Kopper Kettle Inn Restaurant - Morristown

A panel of experts partnered with 10Best editors to pick the initial 20 nominees, and the top 10 winners were determined by popular vote..

Congratulations to all these winning restaurants!

License the 10Best Readers' Choice Award Logo

 

Advertisement

AlertThe Experts

Jennifer L. Rubenstein

Jennifer L. Rubenstein

Jennifer L. Rubenstein

10Best Editors

10Best Editors

10Best Editors

×