Best Historic Hotel (2016)


Each of these classic lodgings, nominated for the title of Best Historic Hotel by a panel of hotel experts, has witnessed a great deal of history, and each has held true to its historic roots and unique sense of place.

  • Mission Inn Hotel & Spa

    Mission Inn Hotel & Spa
    Riverside, Calif.

    The Mission Inn Hotel & Spa, a National Historic Landmark, started out modestly as a 12-room adobe boarding house in the late 1800s when wealthy East Coast residents and Europeans began moving to Riverside, Calif. for the warm weather and growing citrus industry. Today, the charming AAA Four Diamond hotel offers 238 guest rooms and some of the most stunning hotel architecture out there.
    Photo courtesy of Mission Inn Hotel & Spa

  • The Peabody Memphis

    The Peabody Memphis

    The grande dame of Southern hotels, the historic Peabody, is a treat for the senses; opulence abounds, a dynamite restaurant pleases the palate and the famed ducks entertain both adults and children at this hotel dating back to 1869 (it's been at its current location since 1925). The old time-y pool area is a throwback to the glamour days of indoor hotel pools.
    Photo courtesy of Jack Gruber

  • Grand Hotel

    Grand Hotel
    Mackinac Island, Mich.

    Guests at the Grand Hotel on Mackinac Island might find themselves on rocking chairs on the world's longest porch overlooking the Straits of Mackinac. This historic hotel opened in 1887 to cater to summer vacationers from Chicago Montreal and Detroit. In 1895, Mark Twain gave lectures in the Grand Hotel Casino for $1 a ticket.
    Photo courtesy of Laura Bly / USA TODAY

  • Condado Vanderbilt Hotel

    Condado Vanderbilt Hotel
    San Juan, P.R.

    The Condado Vanderbilt Hotel opened its doors in 1919 and quickly became a popular retreat for European royalty and Hollywood celebrities alike. The resort has since been carefully refurbished, but stellar service and luxurious amenities remain front and center at this San Juan hotel.
    Photo courtesy of Condado Vanderbilt Hotel

  • The Hermitage Hotel

    The Hermitage Hotel

    The historic Hermitage Hotel was constructed in 1908 as Nashville’s first million-dollar hotel. No expense was spared in adorning the Beaux-Arts building with a grand staircase, mahogany-paneled guestrooms, Italian marble columns, a painted glass skylight and Circassian walnut cabinetwork. Numerous presidents and dignitaries number among the guests of this Nashville icon.
    Photo courtesy of Preferred Hotels & Resorts

  • French Lick Resort

    French Lick Resort
    French Lick, Ind.

    Established in 1845, French Lick Resort in French Lick, Ind. has undergone extensive refurbishment and restoration to make it look much like it did during its original golden days. For some 200 years, travelers have been coming to the area for the medicinal Pluto Mineral Springs, which guests of the resort can still enjoy today, along with modern amenities like high speed internet, a 27,000-square-foot spa and an 18-hole Donald Ross golf course.
    Photo courtesy of Preferred Hotels & Resorts

  • The American Club

    The American Club
    Kohler, Wis.

    The prestigious American Club began as a housing unit for single immigrant workers at the Kohler company in 1918 – it included a pub, bowling alley, barbershop and offered English lessons for workers. In 1981, the property re-opened as a luxury retreat, now famous for its world-class golf courses, award-winning restaurants and a Forbes Five Star spa.
    Photo courtesy of American Club

  • The Broadmoor

    The Broadmoor
    Colorado Springs

    The history of The Broadmoor – an iconic hotel in Colorado Springs – dates back to 1918 when it welcomed its first guests. John D. Rockefeller was the hotel's first celebrity guest, staying the night of June 1, 1918. Today, the 5,000-acre resort offers a full-service spa, three golf courses and one of the nation's top hotel restaurants, The Penrose Room.
    Photo courtesy of Preferred Hotels & Resorts

  • Loews Don CeSar Hotel

    Loews Don CeSar Hotel
    St. Pete Beach, Fla.

    This historic St. Pete Beach hotel, part of the Historic Hotels of America, is known as the “Pink Palace,” for its colorful rose exterior. Inside, guests and staff often claim to experience paranormal activity. Some rooms are rumored to be haunted, and visitors can sign up for ghost tours of the area that include the Don CeSar. As the stories go, perhaps the ghost here is the original owner and his forbidden lover, or patients who died here when the hotel was using as a veteran hospital in the ‘40s.
    Photo courtesy of Loews Hotels & Resorts

  • Wentworth Mansion

    Wentworth Mansion
    Charleston, S.C.

    Located in charming Downtown Charleston, Wentworth Mansion offers 21 luxe rooms in one of the city's grandest estates. The hotel, built in 1886, had its start as the private mansion of a wealthy cotton merchant. Touches include Italian crystal chandeliers, marble fireplaces, gas fireplaces, day beds, over-sized whirlpool tubs and walk-in showers.
    Photo courtesy of Wentworth Mansion


In addition to our expert panel's input, 10Best editors considered industry awards and guest reviews to determine our 20 nominees. 10Best readers had four weeks to vote daily for their favorites.

The top 10 winners in the category Best Historic Hotel are as follows:

  1. Mission Inn Hotel & Spa - Riverside, Calif.
  2. The Peabody Memphis - Memphis
  3. Grand Hotel - Mackinac Island, Mich.
  4. Condado Vanderbilt Hotel - San Juan, P.R.
  5. The Hermitage Hotel - Nashville
  6. French Lick Resort - French Lick, Ind.
  7. The American Club - Kohler, Wis.
  8. The Broadmoor - Colorado Springs
  9. Loews Don CeSar Hotel - St. Pete Beach, Fla.
  10. Wentworth Mansion - Charleston, S.C.

A panel of experts partnered with 10Best editors to picked the initial 20 nominees, and the top 10 winners were determined by popular vote. Experts Lawrence Horwitz (Historic Hotels of America and Historic Hotels Worldwide), Marla Cimini (USA TODAY), Christopher Parr (Pursuitist) and Yasmin Pullman (Luxury Travel Diary) were chosen based on their luxury travel experience.

Other nominated hotels included Biltmore Hotel in Miami, Green Park Inn in Blowing Rocks, Hilton Chicago, The Jefferson in Washington, Omni Bedford Springs Resort in Bedford, Palmer House in Chicago, The Plaza in New York, The Royal Hawaiian in Honolulu, St. Regis New York and The Willard InterContinental in Washington.

Congratulations to all our winning historic hotels.

License the 10Best Readers' Choice Award Logo



AlertThe Experts

Lawrence Horwitz

Lawrence Horwitz

Lawrence Horwitz

Marla Cimini

Marla Cimini

Marla Cimini

Christopher Parr

Christopher Parr

Christopher Parr

Claire Endean-Cance

Claire Endean-Cance

Claire Endean-Cance