This popular island hangout is THE place on Sanibel Island to catch a sporting event. Inside, you'll find a veritable shrine to sports – from autographed pictures of Brooks Robinson and Bobby Hull, to assorted "tools of the trade" and posters galore – all part of Southwest Florida's largest personal collection of authentic sports memorabilia. You can always find something sports-worthy to talk about here, and such conversations always go down better when chased by a few cold ones and some fried shrimp. The Sanibel Grill features awesome prices during happy hour, which runs daily from 4-6 p.m. and 10 p.m to close.