New in 2013, the Shallow Grave won raves from locals and is back with two houses in 2014. Its theme follows graveyard caretaker-turned-cannibal Thaddeus Van Buren – and his seemingly innumerable terrible deeds – from the Haunted Hills house, which gives his basic story to ADHD attraction, which owner Joe Phillips calls "phobia-based." Careful, you may leave Winter Haven with a few new ones to discuss with your therapist. Small groups enter at intervals, which means there's no chance anyone up ahead will spoil the scares. Depending on your haunted house tolerance, this could be a great thing – or something very, very bad. Happy Halloween!