Explore Indianapolis

Also Featured In

Save This Page +

Photo courtesy of Sullivan's Steak House

Sullivan's Steak House

Cuisine: American, Steakhouse

Price Range: $$$

10Best Says

As the name and decor suggest, this establishment takes inspiration from legendary boxer, John L. Sullivan. Large steaks are the focus, although a small selection of pork chops, filets, and seafood is also available. The carefully considered interior includes a large Art Deco sculpture to greet guests as they enter, and black and white photos of the restaurant's namesake and of other esteemed boxers.

Address:

3316 E 86th St
Indianapolis, IN 46240-2429
317-580-1280

Hours:

Lunch: Mon-Fri 11:30am-2pm
Dinner: Mon-Fri 5:30pm-11pm; Sat-Sun 5:30pm-10pm

Website:

sullivansteakhouse.com

Cocktails Menu
- Martinis
  
  The Knockout
  
  Our Signature Martini: SVEDKA Clementine Vodka Infused with Fresh Hawaiian Gold Pineapple ($12.00)
  
  Sidecar
  
  Hennessy VS Cognac, Cointreau, Lemon ($12.00)
  
  Vesper
  
  Plymouth Gin, ABSOLUT Vodka, Lillet Blanc ($12.00)
  
  French 75
  
  Hendrick's Gin, St-Germain, Lemon, Prosecco ($12.00)
  
  Hemingway
  
  Mount Gay Rum, Luxardo Maraschino, Grapefruit ($12.00)
  
  Blood & Sand
  
  Glenfiddich Scotch, Carpano Antica, Luxardo Morlacco, Orange, Hibiscus ($12.00)
  
  Hibiscus Cosmopolitan
  
  Ketel One Vodka, St-Germain, Hibiscus, Cranberry, Lime ($12.00)
  
  20-Stir Martini
  
  Elyx Vodka, Dry Vermouth ($12.00)
  
  Blueberry Lemon Drop
  
  Smirnoff Blueberry Vodka, Triple Sec, Lemon ($12.00)
  
  Manhattan
  
  Maker's 46 Bourbon, Carpano Antica, Angostura ($12.00)
- Craft Cocktails
  
  French Fashioned
  
  Courvoisier VS Cognac, St-Germain, Peach Bitters, Prosecco ($13.50)
  
  Mint Julep
  
  Woodford Reserve Bourbon, Fresh Mint, Club Soda ($13.50)
  
  Perfect Patrón Margarita
  
  Patrón Silver Tequila, Cointreau, Lime, Agave ($13.50)
  
  Moscow Mule
  
  Tito's Handmade Vodka, Ginger Beer, Lime ($13.50)
  
  Boulevardier
  
  Knob Creek Bourbon, Carpano Antica, Campari ($13.50)
  
  Fig Rosemary Smash
  
  Rémy Martin VSOP Cognac, Fig Preserves, Fresh Rosemary, Lemon, Bittermens Scarborough ($13.50)
  
  The Ice & the Rye
  
  Knob Creek Rye, Cointreau, Mixed Berry Preserves, Fresh Mint, Lemon ($13.50)
  
  Barrel-aged Vieux Carré
  
  House-Aged Bulleit Rye, Rémy Martin VSOP Cognac, Carpano Antica, B&B Benedictine, Peychaud's, Angostura ($13.50)
Bar Menu
- To Share
  
  Filet Wellington Bites*
  
  Thin-Sliced Filet, Bacon Duxelle, Crisp Pastry & Béarnaise Sauce ($15.00)
  
  Chorizo Stuffed Dates
  
  Toasted Almonds, Blue Cheese, Basil Oil & Sherry Honey Glaze ($10.00)
  
  Sriracha Shrimp Lettuce Cups
  
  Sweet & Spicy Chili Glaze, Sesame Seeds & Chives ($10.00)
  
  Tuna Poke Shooters*
  
  English Cucumbers, Mango, Ponzu & Avocado ($13.00)
  
  Artisan Meat & Cheese Board
  
  Olives, Cornichon Pickles & Crisp Baguette ($15.00)
  
  Devilish Oysters Rockefeller
  
  Topped with Nueske's Thick-Cut Bacon & Creamed Spinach ($15.00)
  
  Truffle Steak Tartare*
  
  Challah Toast, Cornichons & Pickled Shallots ($12.00)
  
  Cheesesteak Eggrolls
  
  Sweet & Spicy Chili Sauce & Honey Mustard ($13.00)
- For Yourself
  
  Benko Burger*
  
  Prime Aged Beef, Cheddar, Arugula, Sweet Pickle Dressing, Tomato Jam, Brioche Bun & Fries ($14.00)
  
  Charcuterie Chopped Salad
  
  Pepperoni, Salami, Romaine, Carrots, Celery, Cucumbers, Olives, Egg & Blue Cheese Vinaigrette ($13.00)
  
  IPA Battered Shrimp & Chips
  
  Roasted Garlic Tartar Sauce, Fries & Charred Lemon ($15.00)
  
  Steak Frites*
  
  Gorgonzola Garlic Butter, Roasted Garlic & Fries ($20.00)
Dinner Menu
- Starters
  
  Cheesesteak Eggrolls
  
  Sweet & Spicy Chili Sauce, Honey Mustard ($13.00)
  
  Fresh Seared Rare Ahi Tuna*
  
  Pickled Ginger & Spicy Mustard Sauce ($16.50)
  
  Crispy Shanghai Calamari**
  
  Sweet Chili Glaze, Bean Sprouts, Cherry Peppers, Crushed Peanuts & Scallions ($16.00)
  
  Lump Crab Cake
  
  Cabbage Slaw & Roasted Garlic Tartar Sauce ($17.00)
  
  Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
  
  Cocktail Sauce, Louie Sauce & Lemon ($17.00)
  
  Oysters on the Half Shell*
  
  Cocktail Sauce, Horseradish & Saltines ($16.50)
- Soups & Greens
  French Onion Soup
  
  Gruyère, Swiss & Parmesan Cheese ($9.00)
  
  Shrimp & Lobster Bisque
  Shrimp, Lobster, Sherry & Cream
  
  Cup: $8.00
  
  Bowl: $9.50
  Market Fresh Greens
  
  Cherry Tomatoes, Radish, Shaved Gruyère Cheese & Shallot-Dijon Vinaigrette ($7.50)
  
  Iceberg Lettuce Wedge
  
  Vine Ripe Tomatoes, Crumbled Blue Cheese & Blue Cheese Dressing ($8.00)
  
  Caesar Salad
  
  Heart of Romaine, Shaved Parmesan, Toasted Crouton, Creamy Caesar Dressing & Anchovies ($9.00)
  
  Tableside BLT Salad
  
  Arugula, Vine Ripe Tomatoes, Crisp Bacon, Blue Cheese & Sweet Basil Vinaigrette ($9.00)
  
  Steakhouse Salad
  
  Broiled Sliced Strip Steak, Deviled Egg, Mixed Greens, Avocado, Bacon, Parmesan, Blue Cheese & Lemon-Horseradish Dressing ($26.00)
- Sullivan's Bone-In Cuts
  
  Bone-In Filet
  
  ($65.00)
  
  Bone-In Ribeye Cowboy Cut*
  
  ($46.00)
  
  Wagyu Bone-In Strip
  
  ($69.00)
  
  Bone-In KC Strip*
  
  ($45.50)
  
  Dry-Aged Long-Bone Ribeye*
  
  ($59.00)
  
  Long-Bone Berkshire Pork Chop*
  
  Chipotle Peach Salsa ($39.00)
  
  Roasted Rack of Lamb*
  
  Grain Mustard-Rosemary Glaze ($43.00)
- Signature House-Cut Steaks
  Filet Mignon*
  8 Oz: $39.00
  
  12 Oz: $44.00
  Ribeye*
  
  ($44.00)
  
  New York Strip*
  
  ($39.00)
- Enhance Your Steak
  
  Oscar Style
  
  Lump Crab, Asparagus & Béarnaise ($11.00)
  
  Signature Butters
  
  Cajun, Gorgonzola Garlic, Cabernet Goat Cheese ($3.00)
- Fresh Seafood & Chicken
  
  Salmon with Sweet Corn Jus*
  
  Fingerling Potatoes, Corn & Sweet Corn Jus ($28.00)
  
  Ahi Tuna Fillet Mignon
  
  Edamame, Tomato Medley, Orange Segments & Wasabi Vinaigrette ($36.50)
  
  Pan-Seared Sea Bass "Hong Kong Style"
  
  Baby Bok Choy & Sherry-Soy Glaze ($40.00)
  
  Wild Caught King Crab Legs
  
  1 lb, Steamed, Melted Butter & Lemon ($40.00)
  
  1 Pound Lobster Tail
  
  Simply Broiled, Carved Tableside & Served with Drawn Butter ($60.00)
  
  Herb Brick Chicken
  
  Garlic Fingerling Potatoes, Cherry Peppers & Balsamic Cipollini Onions ($29.00)
- Side Dishes
  
  Salt-Crusted Idaho Baked Potato
  
  ($7.50)
  
  Garlic Horseradish Mashed Potatoes
  
  ($8.00)
  
  Brussels Sprouts**
  
  Bacon, Hazelnuts & Beurre Blanc ($9.50)
  
  Wild Steakhouse Mushrooms
  
  ($9.50)
  
  Fresh Asparagus
  
  Sun-Dried Tomato Hollandaise ($11.00)
  
  Fresh Broccoli
  
  Hollandaise Sauce ($9.00)
  
  White Cheddar & Bacon Au Gratin Potatoes
  
  ($10.00)
  
  Three Cheese Mac
  
  ($10.00)
  
  Cream Style Spinach
  
  ($9.50)
  
  Whole Roasted Cauliflower
  
  Caper Vinaigrette Drizzle ($9.00)
- House-made Desserts
  
  Chocolate Meltdown
  
  Tableside Presentation. Hot Chocolate Sauce and Ganache Dome reveal a Flourless Chocolate Torte, Chocolate Mousse & Fresh Raspberries ($12.00)
  
  Key Lime Pie
  
  Raspberry Sauce ($8.50)
  
  New York-Style Cheesecake
  
  Graham Cracker Crust & Fresh Strawberries ($8.50)
  
  Bananas Foster Bread Pudding
  
  Caramel Sauce & Vanilla Bean Ice Cream ($8.50)
  
  Nutella Crème Brûlée**
  
  Toasted Hazelnuts, Whipped Cream & White Chocolate ($9.50)
- Featured Wine
  
  Flora Springs
  
  Carbernet Sauvignon, Napa Valley ($99.00)
Lunch Menu
- Starters
  
  Cheesesteak Eggrolls
  
  Sweet & Spicy Chili Sauce, Honey Mustard ($13.00)
  
  Fresh Seared Rare Ahi Tuna*
  
  Pickled Ginger & Spicy Mustard Sauce ($16.50)
  
  Crispy Shanghai Calamari**
  
  Sweet Chili Glaze, Bean Sprouts, Cherry Peppers, Crushed Peanuts & Scallions ($16.00)
  
  Lump Crab Cake
  
  Cabbage Slaw & Roasted Garlic Tartar Sauce ($17.00)
  
  Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail
  
  Cocktail Sauce, Louie Sauce & Lemon ($17.00)
- Soups & Greens
  Iceberg Lettuce Wedge
  
  Vine Ripe Tomatoes, Crumbled Blue Cheese & Blue Cheese Dressing ($8.00)
  
  Market Fresh Greens
  
  Cherry Tomatoes, Radish, Shaved Gruyère Cheese & Shallot-Dijon Vinaigrette ($7.50)
  
  Chicken Caesar Salad
  
  Crisp Romaine Leaves, Parmesan, Fresh Croutons & Creamy Caesar Dressing ($13.50)
  
  Steakhouse Salad*
  
  Broiled Sliced Strip Steak, Deviled Egg, Mixed Greens, Avocado, Bacon, Parmesan, Crumbled Blue Cheese & Lemon-Horseradish Dressing ($16.00)
  
  Chopped Chicken Cobb**
  
  Broiled Chicken Breast, Mixed Greens, Applewood Bacon, Eggs, Onions, Tomatoes, Avocado, Shredded White Cheddar, Almonds, Crumbled Blue Cheese & Sweet Basil Dressing ($14.00)
  
  Charcuterie Chopped Salad
  
  Pepperoni, Salami, Romaine, Carrots, Celery, Cucumbers, Olives, Egg & Blue Cheese Vinaigrette ($13.00)
  
  Tableside BLT Salad
  
  Arugula, Vine Ripe Tomatoes, Crisp Bacon, Blue Cheese & Sweet Basil Vinaigrette ($9.00)
  
  Ahi Tuna Ponzu Bowl*
  
  Spinach, Quinoa, Carrots, Red Cabbage, Mango, Avocado, Cucumbers, Tomatoes & Asian Dressing ($17.00)
  
  French Onion Soup
  
  Gruyère, Swiss & Parmesan ($9.00)
  
  Shimp & Lobster Bisque
  Cup: $8.00
  
  Bowl: $9.50
- Lunch Entrées
  Filet Mignon
  Garlic Horseradish Mashed Potatoes, Thin Green Beans & Bordelaise
  
  6 Oz.: $21.50
  
  8 Oz.: $31.50
  Ahi Tuna Fillet Mignon*
  
  Edamame, Tomato Medley, Orange Segments & Wasabi Vinaigrette ($26.00)
  
  IPA Battered Shrimp & Chips
  
  Roasted Garlic Tartar Sauce, Fries & Charred Lemon ($15.00)
  
  Steak Frites*
  
  Gorgonzola Garlic Butter, Roasted Garlic & Fries ($20.00)
  
  Herb Brick Chicken
  
  Garlic Fingerling Potatoes, Cherry Peppers & Balsamic Cipollini Onions ($21.00)
  
  Signature Lump Crab Cakes
  
  Mustard Beurre Blanc Sauce, Cabbage Slaw & Fries ($29.50)
- Sandwiches & More
  
  Napa Valley Chicken Salad**
  
  Truffled Chicken Salad, Roasted Hazlenuts, Grapes, Toasted Challah Bread, Mixed Greens Salad & Fries ($14.00)
  
  Benko Burger*
  
  Prime Aged Beef, Cheddar, Arugula, Sweet Pickle Dressing, Tomato Jam, Brioche Bun & Fries ($14.00)
  
  Shaved Steak French Dip*
  
  Horseradish Sauce, Au Jus & French Fries ($16.00)
  
  Ahi Tuna Burger
  
  Ahi Tuna, Arugula, English Cucumbers, Avocado, Spicy Aioli, Brioche Bun & Fries ($16.50)
- Two Martini Lunch
  
  Vesper Martini
  
  Plymouth Gin, ABSOLUT Vodka, Lillet Blanc ($12.00)
  
  20-Stir Martini
  
  Elyx Vodka, Dry Vermouth ($12.00)
The Sure Thing
- Entrees - Indulge
  Filet Mignon*
  8 Oz: $5.00
  
  12 Oz: $8.00
  New York Strip*
  
  ($5.00)

Disclaimer: Always check with the business for pricing and availability of menu items. SinglePlatform is not responsible for menu or pricing changes, but the information is believed to be accurate when posted. Listing of a menu does not mean that there is any affiliation, endorsement or sponsorship between SinglePlatform and the listed business.