Pubs

Explore Long Island

O'Mally's

Type: Pub

10Best Says

This Irish-style pub, which boasts locations in East Hampton and Southold, offers a laid-back setting where folks can gather, down a few cold pints of stout, and enjoy good conversation with regulars on topics ranging from world events to sports. Added draws are tasty eats, which go above and beyond standard pub fare with marinated steaks and fresh seafood. Burgers, though, earn the loudest applause – the menu features more than two dozen versions, from classic burgers to ones topped with blue cheese.

Address:

Middle Rd
Southold, NY 11971
631-765-2111

Hours:

Mon-Thu: 4:30pm-Midnight
Fri-Sat: 11:30am-Midnight
Sun: Noon-Midnight

Main Menu
- Appetizers
  
  Corn Fritters
  
  sweetly addictive - served with our famous saloon sauce ($6.95)
  
  Beer-battered Onion Rings
  
  a heaping bowlful - with our famous saloon sauce! ($5.95)
  
  Bowl Of Chili
  
  our famous 33 year-old recipe! ($6.95)
  
  Mozzarella Sticks
  
  served with marinara sauce ($8.95)
  
  Fried Mushrooms
  
  served with our famous saloon sauce ($6.95)
  
  Fried Vegetable Platter
  
  corn fritters, cauliflower, broccoli and zucchini sticks, served with our famous saloon sauce and lemon wedge ($11.95)
  
  Original Buffalo Wings
  
  served hot or mild, with our traditional home made sauce ($9.95)
  
  Nachos Omally
  
  topped with melted jack cheese, chili, jalapenos, olives and chopped fresh tomatoes ($9.95)
- Soups & Salads
  Home Made Soup Of The Day
  Cup: $5.95
  
  Bowl: $6.95
  Fresh Mixed Green Salad
  Small: $6.95
  
  Large: $8.95
  Caesar Salad
  
  with our home-made traditonal caesar dressing ($9.95)
  
  Iceberg Wedge
  
  topped with bleu cheese dressing and bacon crumbles ($7.95)
  
  Classic Chopped Salad
- The Burgers
  
  All American Burger
  
  some call this a plain burger. we see it as an opportuntity to really taste great chopmeat, ground fresh daily ($10.95)
  
  American Cheese Burger
  
  cheeseburger. cheeseburger, cheeseburger. ($11.95)
  
  Swiss Cheese Burger
  
  generously topped with melted deli-style swiss cheese. ($11.95)
  
  Bacon Burger
  
  topped with slices of crisp bacon. ($12.95)
  
  Bleu Cheese Burger
  
  crowned with authentic sliced bleu cheese. ($12.95)
  
  Western Chili Burger
  
  topped with omallys home made chili - a 30 year-old recipe! ($12.95)
  
  Fresh Mushroom Burger
  
  topped with freshly-sliced mushrooms. ($11.95)
  
  Reuben Burger
  
  topped with sauerkraut, melted swiss and russian dressing. ($11.95)
  
  Alien Burger
  
  2 hot dogs, steamed in beer. served with sauerkraut, relish, dijon mustard & steak fries ($11.95)
  
  Pizza Burger
  
  topped with melted mozzarella & marinara sauce. ($11.95)
  
  Florentine Burger
  
  topped with spinach, garlic & mozzarella cheese ($12.95)
  
  Romano Burger
  
  topped with breaded eggplant, mozzarella & tomato ($12.95)
  
  Irish Burger
  
  topped with grated spanish onion, fresh bell peppers and dijon mustard ($11.95)
  
  Jogger Burger
  
  topped with sour cream and served with carrot & celery sticks, lemon wedge, lettuce & tomato ($11.95)
  
  Beer And Burger
  
  a plain burger and a frosty mug of beer - no steak fries ($12.95)
  
  Bourbon Burger
  
  topped with our amazing top secret bourbon-sauce recipe! ($12.95)
  
  Italian Burger
  
  topped with melted deli-style mozzarella cheese ($11.95)
  
  Saloon Burger
  
  topped with a spicy home made horseradish & mayonnaise sauce ($11.95)
  
  Vermont Burger
  
  with a hearty cheddar cheese-type topping ($12.95)
  
  Bar-b-que Burger
  
  topped with our special bbq sauce ($11.95)
  
  Texas Burger
  
  with our hickory-smoked bbq sauce ($11.95)
  
  Marinated Burger
  
  our carefully-crafted secret steak marinade ($11.95)
  
  Mexican Burger
  
  ole! guacamole, chopped lettuce & tomato ($12.95)
  
  Appleknocker Burger
  
  cheddar cheese topping & freshly-sliced granny smith apple ($11.95)
  
  Oriental Burger
  
  generously glazed with our honey-and dijon mustard sauce ($11.95)
  
  Buffalo Burger
  
  choose either our home made hot & spicy or mild sauce ($11.95)
  
  Grilled Turkey Burger
  
  grilled all-whitemeat purdue turkey patty ($11.95)
  
  Omallys Minis
  
  2 mini burgers served with american cheese, pickle, chopped onion and steak fries ($10.90)
  
  Garden Burger
  
  dr. praegers meatless mixed-vegetable patty, topped with guacamole, served with black beans . ($11.95)
  
  Bunless Burger
  
  low-carb, high-delicious - served with fresh vegetables & frizzled onions ($13.95)
  
  Burger Papa
  
  melted gorgonzola crumbles & frizzled onions ($12.95)
  
  Super Duper Burger
  
  a huge colossal twin-burger, served on a skewer, with swiss, mozzarella and american cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, mayonnaise & steak fries. ($75.00)
- Guilt-free Dining
  
  Grilled Chicken Salad
  
  fresh chicken, fresh greens, fresh taste ($14.95)
  
  Grilled Chicken Caesar
  
  with our home-made traditonal caesar dressing ($14.95)
  
  Fresh Tomato, Basil & Mozzarella
  
  really, what more could you want? ($12.95)
  
  Veggie Wrap
  
  sauteed fresh vegetables, served with steak fries ($13.95)
  
  Garden Burger
  
  dr. praegers meatless mixed-vegetable patty, topped with guacamole, served with a side of black beans ($11.95)
  
  Bunless Burger
  
  low-carb, high-delicious - served with fresh vegetables & frizzled onions ($13.95)
- Fresh Fish
  
  Fresh Fish Of The Day
  
  ask your server for todays offerings. priced to market.
  
  Fresh Atlantic Salmon
  
  a heart-healthy choice with omega-3 benefits! served with short-grain rice and fresh vegetable ($21.95)
  
  Fish Fillet Sandwich
  
  lightly breaded and fried in soy oil. served with home made coleslaw, tartar sauce & steak fries ($12.95)
  
  Omallys Seafood Basket
  
  fried shrimp, scallops, clams and breaded fillet. served with coleslaw, tartar sauce & steak fries ($19.95)
- Steaks
  
  Chopped Sirloin
  
  served atop toasted italian bread, with sauteed mushrooms and onions. served with baked potato ($15.95)
  
  Sizzling Steak Platter
  
  usda choice sirloin topped with fresh mushrooms and grand marnier sauce ($21.95)
  
  Steak Sandwich
  
  usda choice sirloin, served on toast points. served with steak fries. ($21.95)
  
  Steak Thumbits
  
  sliced usda choice sirloin, served over fresh garlic bread. served with steak fries. ($21.95)
  
  Aged Ny Sirloin
  
  usda choice sirloin, served plain or with our special house marinade. served with baked potato. ($24.95)
  
  Prime Rib Of Beef
  
  a generous cut of usda choice beef served with baked potato & fresh vegetable ($24.95)
- Omallys Bbq
  
  Rack Of Bbq Baby Back Ribs
  
  slow-cooked for over four hours and served with our house-recipe barbecue sauce. served with home made cole slaw & steak fries. ($19.95)
- Poultry
  
  Mexican Chicken Sandwich
  
  fresh grilled chicken breast topped with guacamole, mozzarella, jalapenos & salsa. served with steak fries. ($12.95)
  
  Cheese Chicken Sandwich
  
  fresh grilled chicken breast topped with deli-style mozzarella, swiss & american cheese. served with steak fries. ($12.95)
  
  Mushroom Chicken Sandwich
  
  fresh grilled chicken breast topped with fresh mushrooms & mozzarella. served with steak fries. ($11.95)
  
  Marinated Chicken
  
  fresh grilled chicken breast with a zesty marinade sauce. served with steak fries. ($11.95)
  
  Oriental Chicken Sandwich
  
  fresh grilled chicken breast topped with honey-mustard sauce. served with steak fries. ($11.95)
  
  Chicken Romano Sandwich
  
  fresh grilled chicken breast topped with eggplant, tomato & mozzarella served with steak fries ($12.95)
  
  Italiano Chicken Sandwich
  
  fresh grilled chicken breast topped with mozzarella and marinara sauce. served with steak fries. ($11.95)
  
  Bacon Cheese Chicken Sandwich
  
  fresh grilled chicken breast topped with crisp bacon and mozzarella cheese. served with steak fries ($12.95)
  
  Prize-winning Chicken Burger
  
  lightly fried chicken breast with melted mozzarella, sauteed mushrooms and a garlic-butter sauce. served with steak fries. ($12.95)
  
  Broiled Marinated Chicken
  
  two fresh grilled chicken breasts served over mixed short-grain rice. served fresh vegetable of the day ($14.95)
  
  Chicken Omally
  
  fresh baked chicken breast stuffed with spinach, garlic, sun-dried tomatoes & swiss. served over rice, with fresh vegetable. ($18.95)
  
  Fried Chicken Platter
  
  served with corn bread, honey and steak fries. ($14.95)
- Side Dishes
  
  Baked Potato
  
  ($2.95)
  
  Steak Fries
  
  ($3.25)
  
  Fresh Vegetable
  
  ($4.95)
  
  Sweet Potato Fries
  
  ($4.95)
  
  Corn Bread
  
  ($2.95)

Disclaimer: Always check with the business for pricing and availability of menu items. SinglePlatform is not responsible for menu or pricing changes, but the information is believed to be accurate when posted. Listing of a menu does not mean that there is any affiliation, endorsement or sponsorship between SinglePlatform and the listed business.