10Best from Casual to Haute Lunching in NYC: Midtown Madness at High Noon

Explore New York

Save This Page +

Brother Jimmy's BBQ

Item: Brother Jimmy's BBQ
Author: Maria Lisella

Cuisine: American, Barbecue, Southern

Price Range: $$$

10Best Says

The restaurant's slogan – "Put Some South in Yo' Mouth" - Brother Jimmy's mission is to bring "down-home" cooking, hospitality and merriment to the heart of the Northeast. Over the years, Brother Jimmy's established itself as the home away from home for A.C.C. Alumni. Homesick alums from Duke, UNC, N.C. State, Georgia Tech, U.V.A., Clemson, Maryland, and Wake Forest began to flock to Brother Jimmy's to catch the big Duke/UNC game, or to watch the Demon Deacons take on the Terps. By opening in Manhattan's most popular neighborhoods, Brother Jimmy's found a home in the hearts of not just transplants to the city, but all New Yorkers. 416 8th Ave.; 212-967-7603; TRAINS: A, C, E & Long Island Railroad/Penn Station

Address:

416 8th Avenue
New York, NY 10001
2129677603

Hours:

Lunch: Monday - Friday: 11:30am - 5:00pm Dinner: Monday - Friday: 5:00pm - 12:00am, Saturday: 12:00pm - 1:00am, Dinner: 12:00pm - 11:00pm

Website:

brotherjimmys.com

EXPERT TIPS BY: Maria Lisella
New York Local Expert

Lunch: "On weekends, all the Brother Jimmy's are busy for lunch especially during football season."

Best for Lunch Because: This place reminds southerners what good 'ol Southern hospitality is all about and shows northerners just what they've been missing all these years.

Main Menu
- Beginnings
  
  Hush Puppies
  
  warm maple butter ($8.75)
  
  Frickles
  
  w/ horseradish sauce ($9.50)
  
  Spinach and Artichoke Dip
  
  ($12.00)
  
  Fried Green Tomatoes
  
  w/ spicy aioli ($9.75)
  
  Popcorn Shrimp
  
  w/ cajun mayo ($11.50)
  
  Hot Wings
  
  buffalo, chipotle or crispy naked ($11.50)
  
  Bucket O' Hot Wings
  
  ($21.00)
  
  Jimmy's Burgershack 'Minis'
  
  choose one style: cheeseburgers, turkey burgers and fried buffalo chicken sliders ($12.00)
  
  Quesadilla
  
  w/ salsa and sour cream pulled pork, bbq grilled chicken smoked brisket or veggie ($12.00)
  
  Chicken Fingers
  
  original, buffalo or chipotle ($10.25)
  
  Brother Jimmy's Bbq Nachos
  
  chips, bbq beans, cheese, sour cream, salsa & guacamole served w/ your choice of pulled pork or pulled chicken ($17.75)
  
  Warm Home Made Potato Chips
  
  ($7.75)
- Salads & Stews
  
  House Salad
  
  ($8.50)
  
  Chopped Cobb Salad
  
  romaine lettuce, onion, tomato, bacon bits, crumbled blue cheese, avocado & grilled, fried or buffalo chicken ($15.75)
  
  Jimmy's Wedge
  
  iceberg lettuce, bacon bits, diced tomato, smothered in blue cheese dressing & topped w/ onion rings ($12.00)
- Southern Specialties
  
  Country Fried Steak w/ Gravy
  
  top round steak, tenderized & dredged in our seasoned flour, fried 'til crisp & tender and topped w/ gravy ($20.00)
  
  Fried Chicken Dinner
  
  tossed in our seasoned flour then finished off w/ our southern spice ($19.25)
  
  Blackened Chicken
  
  dipped in our special blackening spice-nice n' spicy ($19.00)
  
  Jimmy's Pig Pick for Four
  
  choose any four of the following items: northern, southern or baby back ribs, pulled pork, brisket, bbq chicken or pulled chicken served w/ your choice of four sides & cornbread ($95.00)
- Bbq Snacks
  
  Bbq Minis
  
  choose any style: pulled pork, pulled chicken or smoked brisket ($12.00)
  
  Bbq Wings
  
  cut wings dusted w/ our southern rub, smoked & basted w/ our special sauce ($12.00)
  
  Rib Tips
  
  northern style ($11.00)
  
  Bucket O' Tips
  
  ($19.50)
- Bbq Platters
  
  Northern Style Ribs
  
  smoked & then grilled w/ brother jimmy's original bbq sauce ($24.75)
  
  Southern Style Ribs
  
  smoked w/ brother jimmy's memphis-style rub ($24.75)
  
  Baby Back Ribs
  
  smoked & finished on the grill w/ a sweet & tangy sauce ($24.75)
  
  Combo Rib Platter
  
  'lil' more than a half rack ($25.75)
  
  Carolina Pulled Pork
  
  pork shoulder slow smoked & pulled w/ brother jimmy's carolina bbq sauce ($18.50)
  
  Pulled Chicken
  
  smoked & pulled w/ brother jimmy's original bbq sauce ($17.75)
  
  Sliced Brisket
  
  smoked for up to 12 hours lean or marbled ($21.00)
  
  1/2 Bbq Chicken
  
  smoked, grilled & basted in brother jimmy's original bbq sauce ($18.50)
  
  Bbq Combo
  
  choose any two bbq meats: pulled pork, pulled chicken, ribs, brisket or bbq chicken
- Bbq Sandwiches
  
  Carolina Pulled Pork
  
  ($12.50)
  
  Pulled Chicken
  
  ($12.50)
  
  Sliced Brisket
  
  lean or marbled ($13.75)
- Sandwiches 'N' Burgers
  
  Blackened Catfish Sandwich
  
  with roasted tomato tartar sauce served w/ avocado & tomato ($13.50)
  
  Bbq Grilled Chicken Sandwich
  
  basted with bbq sauce, served w/ shredded lettuce, tomato and onion ($12.00)
  
  Fried Chicken Sandwich
  
  buffalo style or original ($12.50)
  
  Texas Cheesesteak
  
  smoked brisket with grilled peppers & onions topped w/ brother jimmy's cheese wiz ($13.50)
  
  Bj's Burgers
  
  our half pound custom blend burger grilled to perfection/ ($12.50)
  
  Bj's Signature Bbq Burger
  
  our half pound custom blend basted in chipotle bbq sauce & topped w/ cheddar & onion rings ($13.50)
  
  Turkey Burger
  
  a big version of our mini w/ grilled onions & chipotle bbq mayo ($12.50)
  
  Portobello Burger
  
  grilled portobellos w/ swiss cheese & topped w/ onion rings & chipotle bbq mayo ($12.50)
- Sides
  
  Potato Salad
  
  ($5.25)
  
  Cole Slaw
  
  ($5.25)
  
  French Fries
  
  ($5.25)
  
  Basket of Cornbread
  
  ($5.25)
  
  Sweet Potato Fries
  
  ($5.75)
  
  Spiced String Beans
  
  ($5.75)
  
  Mashed Potato w/ Gravy
  
  ($5.75)
  
  Fried Okra
  
  ($5.75)
  
  Corn on the Cob
  
  ($5.75)
  
  Bbq Baked Beans N' Pork
  
  ($6.50)
  
  Macaroni & Cheese
  
  ($6.50)
  
  Collard Greens
  
  ($6.50)
  
  Fried Brussel Sprouts
  
  ($6.50)
Brunch Menu
- Main
  
  Chicken N' Waffles
  
  ($10.50)
  
  Grilled Cheese
  
  ($8.95)
  
  Beat the Farm
  
  ($9.95)
  
  Bj's Egg Sandwich
  
  ($8.95)
  
  Omelets
  
  ($9.25)
  
  B. L. F. G. T.
  
  ($9.75)
- Sides
  
  Toast or English Muffin
  
  ($2.00)
  
  Ham, Bacon, or Country Sausage
  
  ($4.95)
  
  Home Fries
  
  ($3.25)
  
  Cornmeal Waffle
  
  ($5.00)
- Eye Openers
  
  Bloody Mary
  
  ($9.00)
  
  Bloody Sunday
  
  ($9.00)
  
  Bloody Beer
  
  ($6.00)
  
  White Peach Sangria
  
  ($9.00)
  
  Mimosa
  
  ($7.00)
  
  Bellini
  
  ($7.00)
Drinks Menu
- Concoctions
  
  Honey Badger
  
  woodford reserve, st. germaine, orange juice and honey ($12.00)
  
  Palmetto Punch
  
  oakheart rum, bacardi coco, orange juice, pineapple juice and grenadine ($11.00)
  
  Homeward Bound
  
  sailor jerry rum, fresh lemonade, muddled lemons and a splash of sprite ($11.00)
  
  The Charleston A. P.
  
  sweet tea vodka and lemonade ($11.00)
  
  Jimmy's Ginger Sour
  
  soco lime, fresh lime juice, ginger beer and cranberry juice ($11.00)
  
  Brother Jimmy's Bloody Mary
  
  finlandia vodka and homemade spicy bloody mary mix ($11.00)
  
  The Georgia Tea
  
  old overholt rye, peach schnapps, orange juice, sweet tea and mint ($11.00)
  
  Charlotte Tea
  
  vodka, gin, tequila, bacardi coco, triple sec, sour mix and a splash of coke ($12.00)
  
  Myrtle Beach Margarita
  
  tequila, triple sec, lime juice, sour mix and orange juice add a flavor: strawberry, raspberry, peach, mango or coconut ($11.00)
  
  The Grand Strand Margarita
  
  el jimador tequila, simple syrup, cointreau and muddled limes ($16.00)
  
  Southern Sangria
  
  choose your flavor: red or white ($28.00)
- American Whiskey
  
  Bakers 7 Yr
  
  107 proof ($12.00)
  
  Basil Hayden 8 Yr
  
  80 proof ($11.00)
  
  Blanton's Single-Barrel
  
  92 proof ($11.00)
  
  Bookers
  
  126.6 proof ($15.00)
  
  Knob Creek 9 Yr
  
  100 proof ($8.00)
  
  Knob Creek 9 Yr Single Barrel
  
  120 proof ($9.00)
  
  Woodford Reserve
  
  90.4 proof ($9.00)
  
  Woodford Reserve Dbl Oak
  
  90.4 ($13.00)
  
  Stranahans Colorado Whiskey
  
  94 proof ($13.00)
  
  Michter's Small Batch
  
  91.4 proof ($9.00)
  
  Michter's Single Barrel Rye
  
  84.4 proof ($10.00)
  
  Buffalo Trace
  
  90 proof ($8.00)
  
  Angels Envy
  
  86.6 proof ($10.00)
  
  Maker's Mark
  
  90 proof ($8.00)
  
  Maker's 46
  
  94 proof ($9.00)
  
  Elijah Craig 12
  
  94 proof ($7.00)
  
  John B Stetson
  
  84 proof ($8.00)
  
  Alibi American Whiskey
  
  90 proof ($8.00)
  
  Bulleit
  
  90 proof ($8.00)
  
  Gentleman Jack
  
  80 proof ($9.00)
  
  Jd Single Barrel
  
  94 proof ($13.00)
  
  Templeton Rye
  
  80 proof ($10.00)
- Barrel Aged Whiskey Cocktail
  
  Sweet Cherry Bourbon Slammer
  
  made with woodford reserve ($8.00)
  
  Shot
  
  ($6.00)
  
  Rocks
  
  ($9.00)
  
  Barrel
  
  ($125.00)
- Party Drinks
  
  Swamp Water
  
  our legendary cocktail served in a 64oz fish bowl. hasn't changed in over 25 years! ($25.00)
  
  Trashcan Punch
  
  2.5 gallons of high octane punch served in a mason jar. a perfect drink for a party! ($95.00)
  
  Tower O' Beer
  
  128 ounces of ice cold bud or bud light ($40.00)
  
  Pickleback Shot
  
  tullamore dew irish whiskey and pickle juice ($7.00)
  
  Double Barrel Shot
  
  jack daniels tennessee honey and orange juice ($7.00)
  
  Southern Alibi
  
  alibi american whiskey, peach schnapps and sweet tea ($7.00)
- Draft
  Dogfish Head 60 Minute
  7.1% east coast ipa
  
  $8.00
  
  $30.00
  Sierra Nevada Torpedo
  7.2% west coast ipa
  
  $7.50
  
  $26.00
  Sam Adams
  4.75%
  
  $7.50
  
  $26.00
  Sam Seasonal
  $7.50
  
  $26.00
  Shock Top White
  5.2%
  
  $7.50
  
  $26.00
  Stella Artois
  5.2%
  
  $7.50
  
  $26.00
  Budweiser
  5.0%
  
  $6.50
  
  $22.00
  Bud Light
  4.2%
  
  $6.50
  
  $22.00
  Beer of the Month
- Bottled
  
  Dogfish Head
  
  9% 90 minute ipa ($9.00)
  
  Small Batch 471
  
  9.2% imperial ipa ($9.00)
  
  Victory
  
  9% golden monkey belgian ale ($9.00)
  
  Lagunitas Little Sumpin Sumpin
  
  7.5% wheat ale ($8.00)
  
  Nectar Humboldt
  
  5.7% brown ale ($8.00)
  
  Great Divide Hoss
  
  6.2% rye lager ($8.00)
  
  Captain Lawrence
  
  6.0% belgian ale ($7.00)
  
  Goose Island
  
  5.9% ipa ($7.00)
  
  Sierra Nevada
  
  5.6% pale ale ($7.00)
  
  Bells Two Hearted
  
  7% american ipa ($7.00)
  
  Angry Orchard Cider
  
  5.6% ($7.50)
  
  Corona
  
  4.6% ($7.50)
  
  Heineken
  
  5.1% ($7.50)
  
  Amstel Light
  
  4.6% ($7.50)
  
  Budweiser
  
  5% ($6.50)
  
  Bud Light
  
  4.2% ($6.50)
  
  Miller High Life
  
  4.7% ($6.50)
  
  Michelob Ultra
  
  4.2% ($6.50)
  
  Coors Light
  
  4.2% ($6.50)
- Cansnatural Light
  
  Natural Light
  
  4.3% ($4.75)
  
  Pbr
  
  4.7% ($4.75)
  
  Porkslap
  
  4.3% ($4.75)
- Wines - Red
  Beringer
  pinot noir
  
  Glass: $8.50
  
  Bottle: $34.00
  Beringer
  cabernet sauvignon
  
  Glass: $8.00
  
  Bottle: $32.00
- Wine - White
  Penfolds
  chardonnay
  
  Glass: $8.50
  
  Bottle: $34.00
  Beringer
  pinot grigio
  
  Glass: $8.00
  
  Bottle: $34.00
  Beringer
  sauvignon blanc
  
  Glass: $8.00
  
  Bottle: $32.00
- Wine - Sparkling
  
  Veuve Clicquot
  
  champagne ($100.00)

Disclaimer: Always check with the business for pricing and availability of menu items. SinglePlatform is not responsible for menu or pricing changes, but the information is believed to be accurate when posted. Listing of a menu does not mean that there is any affiliation, endorsement or sponsorship between SinglePlatform and the listed business.