Dave & Andy's Homemade Ice cream is universally accepted as the best ice cream in Pittsburgh – the Pittsburgh City Paper formalized this distinction back in 2000 when they listed Dave & Andy's on their "best of" list. Though the most popular flavor is chocolate chip cookie dough, more adventuresome tasters can try pumpkin ice cream or real cream ice cream (no additional flavorings are added.) And there's a little surprise at the bottom of each homemade waffle cone! ATM onsite.